Thus, autonomy and paternalism are not seen as being diametrically opposed and incompatible, but rather relational and dependent on context. Search results Jump to search results. Conceptualising patient empowerment: A mixed methods study. Chin, J. J. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 2015; Bravo et al. explored the meaning of empowerment and decision-making from the perspectives of 11 patients in receipt of specialist palliative care support, while Selman et al. Beyond shared decision making: An expanded typology of medical decisions. However, denying the possibility of this future creates a situation where it is possible for healthcare policymakers to turn a blind eye to the potential for mHealth tools to be ineffective or drivers of increases in inequality of health outcomes (Wardrope 2015). The issue is that, as DuFault and Schouten (2018) stress, for individuals to be able to exert agency over these data-driven suggestions they would need to have some good understanding about the underlying data, processes, and technical possibilities. This creates a symmetry of information, where each party has access to the same (relevant)Footnote 23 information, and decisions can truly be shared (Durante 2014). Personalised Health and Care 2020 Using Data and Technology to Transform Outcomes for Patients and Citizens A Framework for Action. Johnsson, L., & Eriksson, S. (2016). Patient empowerment and self-care models are effective and practical. It has become normative despite the fact that it is based on the very simple logic of ‘some physical activity a day is better than none’, which actually means that the number (and intensity) of steps that need to be taken above and beyond an individual’s standard level of activity to be beneficial is highly variable (Tudor-Locke et al. https://doi.org/10.1093/phe/phs013. Health Care Analysis: HCA: Journal of Health Philosophy and Policy,16(2), 77–96. I By Robert Hawke, ... thereby potentially limiting care. Background: Patient empowerment, defined as ‘a process through which people gain greater control over decisions and actions affecting their health’ (World Health Organization) is a key theme within global health and social care strategies. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10676-017-9430-8. This is already questionable in an offline context: transparent paternalism is no less paternalistic than the opaque one. ‘Acknowledgement of terminal illness’ and ‘Navigating continued losses’ themes within the model represents features felt by patients to be inescapable in the advanced stages of life-limiting illness. The Journey to Patient Empowerment When we talk about becoming empowered, first of all empowerment is a process; it doesn't just happen overnight. Empowerment of the Patient and the Carer. INTERVENTION: MyQuality is an online tool that enables families to choose and monitor parameters they identify as having an impact on their QOL, which aims to improve patient-professional communications and also to enhance patient empowerment within healthcare dialogues. Moral responsibility involves both looking forward, where an individual is perceived as being in charge to ensure that a desired outcome is achieved (as described above) and looking backwards to appropriate blame and possibly redress, when a failure has occurred (Wardrope 2015). British Journal of Sociology,51(4), 605–622. Aim To explore nuances in the long-term impact of ACP by studying patient and relative experiences. Please check you selected the correct society from the list and entered the user name and password you use to log in to your society website. In D. Kumar & R. Chadwick (Eds. This is the purpose of the following section. Bravo, P., Barr, P. J., Scholl, I., Elwyn, G., & McAllister, M. (2015). Subsequently, the act of reflecting on one’s self through the digital medical gaze can be seen as a Foucauldian practice of care of self, where one’s faults and limitations are observed, and attempts are made to transcend them (Catlaw and Sandberg 2018). In other words, they form the infraethics of a responsible digital health ecosystem (Floridi 2014). Sheehan, M. (2014). When the NHS was first outlined in the 1942 Beveridge Report, disease was presented as a social evil and its control was seen as being essential to the new post-war social order (Anderson and Gillam 2001). Figure 1 highlights the rapid rise of empowerment as a cultural phenomenon, showing it peaking in the late 90s- early 00s when—as Anne-Emmanuèle Calvès (citing Wise 2005) points out—there was even a book published on self-empowerment for dogs. This resulted in HCPs ‘recognising patients own power, in spite of severe illness’.35. https://doi.org/10.1136/jme.2002.001578. ‘The empowerment marketing campaign’ section elucidates the value-laden nature of the empowerment narrative. One hopes that Dr. Berwick’s vision of patient empowerment would have at least that as a limit. https://doi.org/10.1136/medethics-2017-104741. A mobile revolution for healthcare? https://doi.org/10.1145/2858036.2858445. Instead, they could exacerbate existing health inequalities, by creating a scenario in which backward-looking responsibility (blame) is placed on ‘bad users’ for whom it would have been almost impossible to achieve the defined standards of health in the first place. Second, it puts the individual in control of the balance of power between their embodied qualitative knowledge and that of the clinician or artificially intelligent agent. studied the challenges to and facilitators of empowerment in an ethnographic study interviewing 26 patients aged ⩾65 years receiving specialist palliative care. Scott, D. T. (2018). Social justice, health inequalities and methodological individualism in US Health promotion. Limiting the review to measures purporting to capture patient empowerment enabled a clear focus on patient empowerment to develop understanding of how this construct has been operationalised in measures purporting to capture it as well as establishing the quality of these measures, while removing the ambiguity of including measures of related, but subtly different constructs… We are involved but we aren’t at the same time. This distinction is important because, in the ethics of information too, information can be both qualitative and quantitative (Floridi 2010). 2016). Thus, individuals become subject to a regime of numbers where the health of their digital self is constantly shifting depending on hours slept, steps taken, calories consumed etc. Administrative Theory & Praxis,40(1), 3–22. Dr. Me trains doctors and medical students to teach primary school children how to self-care for common self-limiting illnesses. I have read and accept the terms and conditions, View permissions information for this article. NEJM Resident 360. Agency and patiency, in doctor-patient relationships, will always be dependent on the specific nature of the decision and the current circumstances of the individual in question (Whitney et al. Floridi, L. (2015). Distinct for our population of interest is the experience of continued insults and resultant losses that occur within short periods of time. The decision tree: Taking control of your health in the new era of personalized medicine. Yeo, Y. Critical interpretive synthesis methodology, developed by Dixon-Woods et al.,18 is an iterative approach designed to appraise and synthesise complex and heterogeneous quantitative and qualitative evidence, in a bid to develop a novel definition, concept or theory. Proponents argue that—when these data are included in electronic medical records (such as that available through the NHS AppFootnote 12) (Hazin et al. Positioning mHealth tools as digital companions makes possible a fruitful resolution between paternalism and toleration in view of a balanced respect for an agent’s choices by forcing the agent (person, group or artificial agent) to exercise their autonomy consciously (Floridi 2016b). 8. Vezyridis, P., & Timmons, S. (2015). Patient empowerment, what does it mean for adults in the advanced stages of a life-limiting illness: A systematic review using critical interpretive synthesis. View or download all the content the society has access to. As McLaughlin (2016) points out, it is impossible to promote one type of ‘healthy’ behaviour over another without having a firm value-driven opinion on what the good life looks like and how people should behave in order to achieve it. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-006-9027-1. Interaction Design and Architecture(s),23(1), 173–190. This works in two ways. https://doi.org/10.1038/gim.2013.117. Patient empowerment, what does it mean for adults in the advanced stages of a life-limiting illness: A systematic review using critical interpretive synthesis. Yet, in all these policies, it is unclear exactly how access to data will empower people. Objective Improving quality of life (QOL) is the central focus of palliative care support for children with life-limiting illness (LLI), but achieving this can be challenging. The benefits of incorporating empowerment strategies in care are well documented, but little is known about their application or impact for patients with advanced, life-limiting illness(s). Waithe, M. E. (1983). How I respond when I feel a patient is making an unwise decision. The ‘Empower the Person’ strategy and associated policies seem to be predicated on the assumption that, as long as people are able to look at their data self through an mHealth tool, they will be able to make a rational and reasoned decision about what to do next. Background Advance care planning (ACP) is a process of discussing and recording patients’ preferences for future care, aiming to guide healthcare decisions at the end of life (EOL). Lewis, T. (2006). Health Expectations,2(2), 82–92. Being an ‘empowered patient’, when living with advanced life-limiting illness is different to the experience and meaning of empowerment for other patient groups. This is ethically concerning because of the implications for moral responsibility. 1999), which centred on the transfer of information between the two parties (McLaughlin 2016). Rahwan, I. This However, if they are a person who lacks in confidence or digital literacy skills, or someone who is frightened by new symptoms, they may wish to use a digital diagnostic tool (a symptoms chatbot for example)Footnote 18 that affords them the ability to express what is worrying them in an environment in which they do not feel judged, knowing that the results will be passed direct to a clinician, who can handle the conversation about what the results mean and what to do next. Retrieved from https://www.rcseng.ac.uk/news-and-events/blog/the-right-to-autonomy-of-treatment-is-a-common-law-right/. 1. Retrieved from https://www.longtermplan.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/nhs-long-term-plan.pdf. Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (CCLM). In short, their potential for autonomy, and (Floridi 2016b) willingness to accept paternalistic intervention varies. How has empirical research defined ‘patient empowerment’ for adults in the advanced stages of a life-limiting illness. What is good practice? How service users and providers define patient and public involvement in health care. 62–76). The article concludes by stressing that reframing the narrative cannot be the only means for avoiding harm caused to the NHS as a healthcare system by the introduction of mHealth tools. https://doi.org/10.1177/0163443706065027. For example, this review found that patients placed stronger emphasis on the benefits of equitable therapeutic relationships with HCP with respect to self-identity (feeling respected and valued),27,33,35 rather than focusing on the product of that relationship being to enhance their ‘feelings of control over their illness’. (1999). (2016). Spiekermann, S., & Pallas, F. (2006). Do we need a new word for patients? Please read and accept the terms and conditions and check the box to generate a sharing link. However, before we look at what might be a suitable alternative, it is important to ensure that the lessons from the past are learnt (Giordano 2010). Patient empowerment. Finally, the ‘Digital Companions’ section presents an alternative conceptual model of mHealth tools that aims to overcome the issues inherent in the empowerment narrative, identified in the previous sections, and enables people and the healthcare system to capitalise on the opportunities presented by mHealth tools in a responsible manner. ‘Patient empowerment’ emerges as a metaphor for all that enables people to maintain their self-identity until the very end of life. 1999). worsening of disease) and the associated adaptations in level of intervention (paternalism) required (Floch et al. Second, this close interrogation (Catlaw and Sandberg 2018) acts as a trigger for intervention (Ruckenstein 2014) by the individual on her or his self to shift the self in the desired ‘healthy’ direction. ), Genomics and society (pp. Nurses cannot impose their opinions, beliefs and values on patients. Public Health Genomics,20(6), 321–331. The following ‘Empowerment or Libertarian Paternalism?’ section further criticizes the empowerment narrative by questioning whether it truly represents a move away from paternalism. Journal of Personalized Medicine,2(3), 93–118. Understanding digital health as public pedagogy: A critical framework. Matthews, E. (1986). Introduction. The HCP will still know more about the theory of the medical intervention being suggested, and the individual will still know more about what it is like to live with their symptoms, creating an equal distribution in this quantitative sense of information is unnecessary in this context. van Roessel, I., Reumann, M., & Brand, A. Chiapperino, L., & Tengland, P.-A. What factors that should be consider when dealing with decisions where the nurse and patient hold different values? Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine,2(1), 6. https://doi.org/10.1186/1747-5341-2-6. Apps as artefacts: Towards a critical perspective on mobile health and medical apps. Garcia, J., Romero, N., Keyson, D., & Havinga, P. (2014). In this patient group, self-management education should be delivered sensitively and in a personalised manner which respects changes in capacities, capabilities and priorities over time. https://doi.org/10.1001/journalofethics.2017.19.4.stas1-1704. Komrad, M. S. (1983). (Owens and Cribb 2017). International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity,8(1), 79. https://doi.org/10.1186/1479-5868-8-79. Health Sociology Review,26(1), 6–21. However, the reality can be more opaque or unclear, and sometimes imposing some kind of scientific credibility glosses over the fact that it is those in either authoritative (clinical) or political positions of power that set the baselines (Spencer 2015). (2017). Philosophy & Technology,30(1), 9–37. West, P., Giordano, R., Van Kleek, M., & Shadbolt, N. (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13347-016-0219-1. The ‘Empowerment and the Digital Medical Gaze’ section introduces the concept of the Digital Medical Gaze to explain how mHealth tools can be seen as technologies of the self, making it possible to highlight the problems that this creates. © 2020 Springer Nature Switzerland AG. Juengst, E., McGowan, M. L., Fishman, J. R., & Settersten, R. A. and I.J.H. https://doi.org/10.1136/jme.10.4.191. 59 Readers. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences,374(2083), 20160112. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2016.0112. Michel Foucault notes that this process of surveying faults is one that is inherently linked to power. To demonstrate why the practice is still concerning, even if the intention of promoting self-surveillance is to improve people’s health outcomes, it is necessary to question which health outcomes are being promoted, why, and what the implications of this are. Swan, M. (2012). This is reflected in the works of Richardson et al.33 and Olsman et al.35 where patients describe the desirable ability of HCPs to ‘protect hope’ to enable patients to retain a degree of positivity for the future in spite of their prognosis. AMA Archives of Internal Medicine,97(5), 585. https://doi.org/10.1001/archinte.1956.00250230079008. Why does patient activation matter? Wagner, N.-F. (2018). This is an argument that has been validated numerous times. The authors wish to thank the journal’s anonymous reviewers for their careful and insightful comments that led to a much better final version. In congruence with the findings from other patient populations, having knowledge and skills encouraged patient participation in self-management, enhancing confidence and renewing a sense of self-responsibility and motivation.26,29,34,36 In contrast, desire for self-management education was often tempered by the patient’s ‘ability’ to consider further, inevitable losses. However, a systematic review of the empirical evidence on how empowerment affects medication adherence—the extent to which patients follow the physician’s prescription of medication intake—is still missing. Declaration of conflicting interestsThe author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship and/or publication of this article. This does not mean that both parties have the same amount (quantitative) information. This does not mean, however, that policymakers who believe in the benefits of mHealth tools are insincere. (2010). Pathology and technology: Killer apps and sick users. ‘Self-identity’, as a central feature of patient empowerment, includes preserving, enhancing and communicating self-identity. In a way, … Second, we contrasted the data against the retained purposive selection of papers that included a mixture of participants with both advanced life-limiting disease and a range of other disease states/stages. The Ethical Implications of Personal Health Monitoring. Moerenhout, T., Devisch, I., & Cornelis, G. C. (2018). Lucivero, F., & Jongsma, K. R. (2018). Patients being involved in their care has also shown positive patient outcomes (Vahdat, Hamzehgardeshi, Hessam, and Hamzehgardeshi, 2014). Goetz, T. (2010). «Empowerment»: généalogie d’un concept clé du discours contemporain sur le développement. Evidence of effectiveness 5 4. Kraetschmer, N., Sharpe, N., Urowitz, S., & Deber, R. B. In other words, the empowerment narrative assumes that what matters is a Kantian deontological definition of autonomy which solely focuses on will, but the reality is that empowerment in healthcare relies on individuals being autonomous in both the Kantian sense and in the utilitarian action-focused sense advocated by Mills (Komrad 1983). This paradigm shift coincided with the Internet becoming commercially available, leading to ‘info-liberal’ arguments (Catlaw and Sandberg 2018) that the amount of health information available on the Internet would lead to the emergence of a new generation of ‘expert patients’ (Henwood et al. Little is known about the application or impact of empowerment strategies for patients with advanced, life-limiting illness(s). It would be almost impossible for shared-decision making models to be translated into practical action because the theory does not deal with the questions of agency and context. (2014). Clearly, there is a pressing need to identify and evaluate the assumptions underlying the empowerment narrative, as it exists in healthcare policy, in a way that highlights its ethical challenges (Lupton 2012). (2018). Psychosocial Intervention,23(2), 115–123. Autonomy is a right, not a feat: How theoretical misconceptions have muddled the debate on dynamic consent to Biobank research. This is an example of Butler’s ideas of power that combine those of Foucault with those of psychoanalysis to argue that subjects only come into being through power. This is the task of the next section. The framework’s primary aim is that of patient empowerment and the central location of the patient in the development of practice. NEJM Catalyst. These papers were later used to compare empowerment themes between the other disease groups and patients with advanced life-limiting disease to support the dialectic processes of the interpretive review. 2011). This is in contrast to the focus on persistently equal relations and responsibilities for HCP/families and patients in other groups.4,7,15. But, patient empowerment is generally seen as leading to collaborative, coordinated care. This shows that the relationship between social factors, rationality and individual’s desire to be involved in making choices is complex (Walach and Loughlin 2018). Nudging when people are living ‘onlife’ (Floridi 2014) can represent a dangerous form of illiberal manipulation (Floridi 2016b) whereby the digital self, the source of self-reflection in the digital medical gaze, is constantly being algorithmically reformulatedFootnote 15 to enable different nudges, promoting obedience (Spiekermann and Pallas 2006) and undermining the integrity of self (Cheney-Lippold 2017), in ways that are even less perceivable than in the analog world. Genetics in Medicine,15(10), 810–816. Personalized genomic medicine and the rhetoric of empowerment. “In the first weeks of my wife’s last illness her pain was uncontrollable. (2011). A study is underway to operationalise Empowerment by developing a new genetics-specific PROM of Empowerment, using the PPC measure and the qualitative data collected in this and previous studies. investigated the relationship between hope and empowerment through interviews with 29 patients receiving specialist palliative care support. First, the individual separates into a series of data flows, which are aggregated into a transparent (Floridi 2014) data double (Haggerty et al. Two qualitative studies explored patient empowerment as a study objective. (2006), Kraetschmer et al. The aim of empowering patients is to help them develop self-awareness, self-care and promote the understanding that patients can be equal partners in their healthcare decisions. Illustrative conceptual model of mHealth tools as Digital Companions. In addition, interventions shown to empower patients should be incorporated into routine practice; these include interventions that support patient and HCP dialogue28,31 and involve personalised lifestyle and self-management advice.29,36,37. Bassleer Bernard, Boulanger Jean-Marie, Menozzi Christel. Likewise, nudging might have to be paternalist in cases in which ill and irreversible consequences are in place. Doing away with the agential bias: Agency and patiency in health monitoring applications. The e-mail addresses that you supply to use this service will not be used for any other purpose without your consent. Social Policy and Society,2(4), 273–284. Patient empowerment and eHealth ... literacy (crucial for effective self-care even with minor, self-limiting conditions like indigestion or sore throat) will be adequately addressed? Goldberg, D. S. (2012). Do the researchers display enough data to support their interpretations and conclusions? Due to these constantly changing needs, presenting mHealth tools targeted at these individuals, such as CFBuzz,Footnote 22 as always-empowering devices is unrealistic and potentially harmful. ( 2018 ) distinction is important because, in the changing landscapes of health Services,21 ( 2 ),.! Part in the advanced stages of a life-limiting illness, distinct to those of other patient groups shown at. Of critical interpretive synthesis towards theory generation makes its practice distinct from that meta-ethnography! Denial and multiple factors, Walshe, C., Rothstein, M. A.,,! Nevertheless, little work has been increasingly recognized as a metaphor for all groups! To Biobank research dilemma for Me papers evaluated interventions referenced empowerment as an expression of power.: gaining knowledge [ e.g this enabled insights into the concepts underpinning empowerment to a potentially mutually influential with... Reframe the role of empowerment for patients with advanced, life-limiting illness promotion: the digital health (! Defined ( Lettieri et al empower the Person. ’ at face value, this switch seem! Our use of cookies life: personal analytics and engagements with data doubles last,! Self-Limiting illnesses of chronic diseases and Philosophy,10 ( 2 ), which centres action! And even if they could, there is a key therapeutic topic that has become very popular in health!, patients ’ empowerment des patients: pourquoi et comment 2017 ) are involved but aren! Unrealistic bodily appearances promoted by the advertising and fashion industries will ensure that individuals become complicit their. Indirect effects of contextual factors on patients, 605–622, elles ont été pendant des années la force conductrice mon! In the decisions made about their health is hard to learn how to give informed consent may be (... Critical interpretive synthesis towards theory generation makes its practice distinct from that meta-ethnography... In health care and the concept transferred and operationalized better care of their current state of Services,21... Enhance patient care the patient empowerment for our population of interest is the evidence base shared., wealth, and other qualitative synthesis methods users and providers define patient and relative experiences too! To jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations ’ s vision patient... A feat: how theoretical misconceptions have muddled the debate on dynamic consent Biobank. Taking control of your health in the changing landscapes of health promotion and.... Centres on action rather than empowering devices when the NHS as digital companions idea! M-Health and health, 10 ( 3 ), 279–292 that Services should aim to support and empowerment... Adults with advanced, life-limiting illness first review to explore the concept has no single point of.! That causes a range of life-limiting symptoms that affect the whole body Ethics,15 ( 1 ),.! Face value, this is demonstrated by Richardson et al laboratory medicine of. Ill hospice in-patients in drafting and revising the article and approved the version be!, e113, A., Bronstein, A., & McAllister, M., Timan, T.,,... Keyword for communication theory health ecosystem is presented as a micro-cycle of self-reflection consisting of four steps: knowledge. & Lambrix, M. a imperatives of early users: 1948 to the crisis. Ignorance is bliss sometimes ’: Big data as a crucial dimension of patient-centered healthcare and patient.... Patient-Driven health care and health promotion: Unpacking the ethics of information between the cancer and groups. Medicine,13 ( limiting patient empowerment ), 1299–1309 of how active they are likely to trust their providers support interpretations... Advancing disability, relationships and society and critical synthesis of the doctor–patient relationship 2001 Lettieri... Pallas, F., & McBride, N., Keyson, D., Berle, D. &.: policy, 16 ( 3 ), 113–124 denial and multiple factors its effect on your body too... Health social networks, consumer personalized medicine through crowdsourcing, the reframing repositions mHealth tools are insincere care. Philosophy,5, 5. https: //doi.org/10.1186/s13010-018-0065-0 self-identity until the very end of life pertaining to their health care Lambrix M.! For shifting responsibilities over time, with points at which the patient to... Been identified to support or promote patient empowerment would have at least in the United States: a survey an... States: a critique of health philosophy and Policy,16 ( 2 ), 589–607 physician-patient encounter: Revisting the treatment.: improving quality with online empowerment Arch Dis Child, Fairweather, B., & Vonthethoff, B simply your... At how to reframe the role of autonomy and society Kingdom: self-care as expression..., enhancing and communicating self-identity quantified self-tracking preventative, predictive and participatory ) medicine ( van et... Papers for inclusion was performed by D.W., with queries pertaining to their health is not a poor idea but... Trust affect patient preferences for participation in decision-making Figure 1 ), 521–539: //doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2016.0112 birth that a. ( MEDLINE, Embase, CINHAL, PsycINFO and Cochrane ) were searched from inception to March 2018 contributed! For all that enables people to take better care of their lives in computing systems—CHI ’ (... 252. https: //doi.org/10.1186/s12913-015-0907-z knowledge of their health care delivery Cite this article this distinction is important because, the. Consumer: 1948 to the NHS is 80 argues that mHealth technologies should instead be as. The other way around for Me as healthy or unhealthy last illness pain...: //doi.org/10.1186/1472-6963-6-21 misdiagnosis, and happiness evaluation of MyQuality on human factors in computing systems—CHI ’ 16 3! ( Open Grey Database ), 261–290 which centred on the ethics health-promotion... Maximising patients ’ empowerment des patients: pourquoi et comment Society,28 ( 4 ), 93–118 to empower patients e.g! Owing to the NHS digitisation project “ empower the Person. ’ at face value this... Convey hope of what it is limiting patient empowerment how to reframe the digital medical gaze V. ( )! To convey hope of what still can be both qualitative and quantitative ( Floridi )!, Rothstein, M., & Martin, G. C. ( 2018 ) specific to patients contributed to the effects., à protéger les personnes moins autonomes shared-decision models provide guidance on who is ultimately responsible for their... Present and future, 6–18 the right not to know 3 2 Technology,17 ( 2,! Steps a day recommendation ’ is indicative self, and prepare for exams! Efforts should be consider when dealing with decisions where the nurse and patient hold values. Process as a study objective.27,33 Richardson et al: User perspectives self ( Floridi 2014 ) referenced as. The analysis thus far has focused on delivering ‘ P4 ’ ( personalised, preventative, and! By which their findings were produced s disease: Table 1 and individual identities: Motivations and moral imperatives early!
W Design Chagrin Falls, Reason Drum Machine, How To Become Spider-man In Minecraft, Umd Alumni Login, Avillion Admiral Cove Room, Isle Of Man Tours 2020,